(Chief Burgess title was changed to Mayor in June 1961.)
| 1876 | D.P. Haupt | 1904-13 | Samuel Steinbach |
| 1877 | Joseph Beatty | 1914-17 | H. E. Madara |
| 1878-79 | D.P. Haupt | 1918-20 | Ray Burchill |
| 1880 | P. Zimmerman | 1920-21 | H. E. Madara |
| 1881 | Jacob Rauch | 1922-25 | Harry Wood |
| 1882 | John M. Thomas | 1926-50 | George Miller |
| 1883-84 | J.B. Nice | 1922-25 | Harry Wood |
| 1885-86 | Frederick Sanner | 1926-50 | George Miller |
| 1887 | Thomas Irvin | 1950-53 | James Amour |
| 1888 | Robert Coxon | 1954-61 | William J. Miller |
| 1889 | Jeremiah Foulk | 1962-67 | Andrew Yesalusky |
| 1890 | Daniel J. Kiefer | 1967-69 | Walter Stepenaskie |
| 1891 | William W. Wertz | 1970-73 | Metro Karlitskie |
| 1892 | James Kelly | 1974-80 | James Nahas |
| 1893-95 | E.J. Douden | 1981-93 | Raymond Tomko |
| 1895-96 | George W. Wagner | 1994-97 | Charles Brayford |
| 1897-00 | Reuben Wagner | 1998-02 | Thomas Hombosky |
| 1900-02 | H.P. Price | 2002-05 | Nicholas Borzak |
| 1903 | John Madara | 2006 | Delmar Phillips |